Portal Login:
  • Clients
  • Providers
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
    Portal Login:
  • Clients
  • Providers
  • About MCN
  • Careers
  • MCNTalk
  • Contact Us

MCN | Medical Consultants Network

The Power of a Second Look

  • Services
    • Independent Medical Examinations
    • Medical Peer Reviews
    • Bill Review Services
    • Utilization Reviews
  • Expertise
    • Short and Long-Term Disability
    • Workers’ Compensation
    • Auto/PIP/Casualty/Liability
    • Independent Review Organization Services
  • For Clients
  • For Providers
  • Your Exam
    • About Your Exam
    • About Your External Review
    • Contact & Scheduling
  • Schedule Now
  • About MCN
  • MCNTalk
  • Careers
  • Contact Us

MCNTalk
News, Insights & Opinions

Home / MCNTalk / When Is Spoken Conversation not a Matter of Free Speech?

September 30, 2014

When Is Spoken Conversation not a Matter of Free Speech?

When it is “medical treatment,” apparently. According to a 2-1 decision this past summer by the United States Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit. Specifically, everything a doctor says to a patient is “treatment,” not speech, and the government has broad authority to prohibit doctors from asking questions on particular topics.

As background, in 2011 the Florida Firearm Owners Privacy Act was passed, which threatens doctors with professional discipline if they ask patients whether they own guns or record the resulting information in a patient’s files when doing so is not “relevant” to a patient’s medical care. “Relevant” is not defined, and no provisions for establishing relevancy are outlined. The constitutionality of this Act was questioned and ultimately upheld by this summer’s Wollschlaeger v. Governor of Florida ruling.

Is the 2011 law necessary in any way? Opponents of Florida’s law, including the Brady Campaign to Prevent Gun Violence, believe the opposite, that asking patients about gun ownership is a legitimate means of promoting public health by giving doctors the opportunity to share firearms-safety tips. As this Times editorial notes, “the First Amendment generally doesn’t let the government outlaw the asking of annoying questions. Instead, people can refuse to answer or decline to associate with those who insist on asking such questions” and asks us to:

Imagine if tobacco companies successfully lobbied for a law that prohibited doctors from asking patients whether they smoke. Some doctors may want to know so they can conduct lung examinations, while others may just want to urge their patients to stop. But everyone should recognize that a law outlawing a simple question infringes on speech.

 

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Email
  • More
  • Facebook
  • Reddit
  • Print

Tagged: Government Policy, Legal Issues 3 Comments

Previous Post
Next Post

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. L Brown says

    October 1, 2014 at 10:50 am

    Doctors should not be asking patients about gun ownership. Otherwise start asking if the hike in treacherous terrain, own ATVs, own archery equipment, ride a skateboard etc. The list goes on.

    Reply
  2. Beverly says

    October 31, 2014 at 11:58 am

    I believe that if a Psych doctor feels that a patient is mentally unstable (ie: suicidal or homicidal) then asking if the patient owns a gun could be extremely relevant!

    Reply
  3. your health today says

    October 26, 2016 at 4:55 pm

    When it is “medical treatment,” apparently. According to a 2-1 decision this past summer by the United States Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit. Specifically, everything a doctor says to a patient is “treatment,” not speech, and the government has broad authority to prohibit doctors from asking questions on particular topics.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Recent Posts

  • The Quality Divide: What Makes a Quality IME Physician?
  • The Quality Divide: Is Your Vendor Driving IME Excellence?
  • The Quality Divide: When and How to Request an IME?
  • April Clinic Calendars Are Available
  • MCN’s Client Portal Login Page is Changing

Archives

Footer


  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn

Quick Links

  • Services
  • Expertise
  • About MCN
  • Careers

Division Headquarters

MCN
1200 5th Ave., Ste. 650
Seattle, WA 98101

See all offices

Email Us

General Inquiries: info@mcn.com
Sales & Marketing: marketing@mcn.com

Call Us

206.343.6100
800.248.6269

© Copyright 2023 Mitchell International, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

  • Privacy Policy
  • Sitemap