Portal Login:
  • Clients
  • Providers
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
    Portal Login:
  • Clients
  • Providers
  • About MCN
  • Careers
  • MCNTalk
  • Contact Us

MCN | Medical Consultants Network

The Power of a Second Look

  • Services
    • Independent Medical Examinations
    • Medical Peer Reviews
    • Bill Review Services
    • Utilization Reviews
  • Expertise
    • Short and Long-Term Disability
    • Workers’ Compensation
    • Auto/PIP/Casualty/Liability
    • Independent Review Organization Services
  • For Clients
  • For Providers
  • Your Exam
    • About Your Exam
    • About Your External Review
    • Contact & Scheduling
  • Schedule Now
  • About MCN
  • MCNTalk
  • Careers
  • Contact Us

MCNTalk
News, Insights & Opinions

Home / MCNTalk / Are Surgical Robots Worth the Cost?

July 9, 2012

Are Surgical Robots Worth the Cost?

by Brian L. Grant, MD

A series of articles in the Sunday Seattle Times presented interesting and provocative news regarding our health care industry.

The lead article, “Use of surgical robots booming despite hefty cost” by Carol Ostrom describes the medical arms race in the form of surgical robots. The value of these devices are debated relative to costs and clearly the technology carries a steep price– $2.6 million for the da Vinci surgical robot. A related article shows how  a small community hospital in Pullman, WA invested in the multimillion robotic device  in order to attract surgical talent. Pullman Regional’s CEO Scott Adams said he advocated to make the hefty investment because a urologist can bring $2 million a year to the hospital. No matter that the sort of elective surgery these robotic devices enable can be performed quite competently without the robots or with them at a larger regional center a relatively short drive away. The key driving force  for these new age devices is economical. These decisions are multiplied  with other costly investments that are overdone and redundant – but whose costs are passed on to insurance carriers and those who pay the premiums or the taxes. In the article, Dr. Marty Makery, a general surgeon and director of surgical quality at John Hopkins said, “Out of all the instruments and surgical tools that hospitals have adopted, this is one of the most expensive items in American operating rooms today. It’s a symbol of what’s wrong with American health care: the widespread adoption of expensive new technology with little evidence to support its use — all within the context of a poorly informed, even misinformed, public.” These costs are paid both on a per surgery basis, but also perhaps in the form of more surgery being performed. Especially is the case in the areas of gynecological procedures like hysterectomy or prostate procedures – many of which are not clinically appropriate and hotly contested. Do we as patients really benefit when unnecessary surgery is done better, if indeed this is the case as device advocates claim?

On the editorial page is an op-ed, “Medical reform, Act II- how best to deliver health care,”  by Dr. David Fleming, the King County (Seattle) director of public health. He displays the well-worn statistics contrasting the U.S. health spend vs. other developed countries, with life expectancy. There is not only no correlation, but there is a negative correlation in the countries highlighted. Could it be our system is sick? Do surgical robots represents part of the symptoms of our illness?  Read More…

47.608945-122.332015

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Email
  • More
  • Facebook
  • Reddit
  • Print

Leave a Comment

Previous Post
Next Post

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Recent Posts

  • The Quality Divide: What Makes a Quality IME Physician?
  • The Quality Divide: Is Your Vendor Driving IME Excellence?
  • The Quality Divide: When and How to Request an IME?
  • April Clinic Calendars Are Available
  • MCN’s Client Portal Login Page is Changing

Archives

Footer


  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn

Quick Links

  • Services
  • Expertise
  • About MCN
  • Careers

Division Headquarters

MCN
1200 5th Ave., Ste. 650
Seattle, WA 98101

See all offices

Email Us

General Inquiries: info@mcn.com
Sales & Marketing: marketing@mcn.com

Call Us

206.343.6100
800.248.6269

© Copyright 2023 Mitchell International, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

  • Privacy Policy
  • Sitemap