Portal Login:
  • Clients
  • Providers
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
    Portal Login:
  • Clients
  • Providers
  • About MCN
  • Careers
  • MCNTalk
  • Contact Us

MCN | Medical Consultants Network

The Power of a Second Look

  • Services
    • Independent Medical Examinations
    • Medical Peer Reviews
    • Bill Review Services
    • Utilization Reviews
  • Expertise
    • Short and Long-Term Disability
    • Workers’ Compensation
    • Auto/PIP/Casualty/Liability
    • Independent Review Organization Services
  • For Clients
  • For Providers
  • Your Exam
    • About Your Exam
    • About Your External Review
    • Contact & Scheduling
  • Schedule Now
  • About MCN
  • MCNTalk
  • Careers
  • Contact Us

MCNTalk
News, Insights & Opinions

Home / MCNTalk / Amid War on a Mystery Disease, Patients Clash With Scientist...

March 25, 2011

Amid War on a Mystery Disease, Patients Clash With Scientists

In addition to providing an update on chronic fatigue research, this article in the Wall Street Journal summarizes some interesting points about the larger question of how illnesses are defined and the interplay between that and treatment research. As MCNTalk noted several weeks ago (What’s in a Name? For Illnesses, it’s Fodder for Debate) treatments may vary depending upon a physician’s diagnostic measurements. In a posting earlier this week (Gene Work Yields New Treatment For Lupus) MCNTalk further explored dilemmas raised by a condition’s definition.

Points to ponder:

  • The Internet has given patients the ability to organize and rapidly disseminate medical information—and rumors as well. Patient advocacy groups are increasingly powerful, involved in central endeavors such as funding research and collecting samples critical to experiments.
  • In the case of chronic fatigue treatment, Stuart Le Grice, head of the National Cancer Institute’s Center of Excellence in HIV/AIDS and cancer virology, is skeptical about XMRV’s role in the disorder. He is sympathetic to patients but he insists that science can’t be rushed. Desperate patients who want immediate answers risk diverting attention from essential research. “There’s a danger of deflecting us from what we really want to do,” Dr. Le Grice says.
  • There has never been any consensus on what causes the syndrome. Many doctors believe that there can be different triggers, including viruses and genetic vulnerability. There are still some doctors who believe the condition is psychiatric, a stance many patients believe has discredited them and slowed down efforts to find treatments.
  • The clashes between patients and scientists come as science in general becomes more polarized, according to a study published in the Journal of Risk Research last year. Researchers found that when scientists’ conclusions conflict with a community’s cultural values, people don’t accept the scientific consensus. “The phenomenon we are looking at is a cultural war over facts,” says Dan Kahan, director of the Cultural Cognition Project at Yale Law School, who co-authored the study last year.

Read more…

47.608945-122.332015

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Email
  • More
  • Facebook
  • Reddit
  • Print

Tagged: Clinical Issues, Health Policy, Sociology and Language of Medicine, The Practice of Medicine 2 Comments

Previous Post
Next Post

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Gregory Sands de Jean says

    March 26, 2011 at 9:23 am

    Very interesting. Thanks for bringing this to light…

    Reply
  2. Dr. Anders VondeGraff says

    March 29, 2011 at 11:39 am

    In Europe, there is a long history of ill defined disease, such as “ME” and, going way back, railway spine. I have no trouble with patients believing they have some disease. I think we need to draw a line, however, with regard to disability certification. If you look closely, many of the patients undoubtedly are receiving disability payments and other recompense for their disease. Most people can work, and these patients would be best served by finding meaningful work. This is an age old problem. What do we do?

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Recent Posts

  • The Quality Divide: What Makes a Quality IME Physician?
  • The Quality Divide: Is Your Vendor Driving IME Excellence?
  • The Quality Divide: When and How to Request an IME?
  • April Clinic Calendars Are Available
  • MCN’s Client Portal Login Page is Changing

Archives

Footer


  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn

Quick Links

  • Services
  • Expertise
  • About MCN
  • Careers

Division Headquarters

MCN
1200 5th Ave., Ste. 650
Seattle, WA 98101

See all offices

Email Us

General Inquiries: info@mcn.com
Sales & Marketing: marketing@mcn.com

Call Us

206.343.6100
800.248.6269

© Copyright 2023 Mitchell International, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

  • Privacy Policy
  • Sitemap